Contact in Spain
Spain: +34 932 20 44 40
UK: 0800 098 8033
US: +1 415 651 8449

Bank ordered to pay back customer €17,000 due to illegal mortgage floor clause

The High Court in Álava province (Basque Country) has declared a so-called ‘clausula suelo‘ – or mortgage floor clause – null and void and ordered the bank in question, Liderbank (formerly Caja Extremadura), to return €17,000 that it received from the customer as a result of the clause that was contained in the mortgage agreement.

The subject of ‘clausulas suelo‘ was recently reviewed by the Supreme Court and is essentially a term of the mortgage agreement that establishes a minimum interest rate. So even though the rate payable may be declared to be a fixed percentage below the European ‘Euribor’ rate, should the Euribor rate fall low enough, the ‘clausula suelo‘ will prevent the bank customer from benefiting from lower repayments.

Unfair and Disproportionate

The High Court in Álava agreed with the Court of first Instance that the clause had to be struck-out of the agreement on the basis that is was ‘unfair’ for being “disproportionate, displaying a lack of reciprocity and was a violation of the doctrine of fair balance in loans”.

The customer had agreed to pay an interest rate of the Euribor rate + 0.65%. However the mortgage agreement included a minimum rate of 4.25% regardless of the Euribor rate and the customer alleged that, since the Euribor rate had fallen below this level that he had paid €17,000 more than he would of if there had been no minimum rate.

The agreement also contained a maximum interest rate of 12% but while the minimum rate had been exceeded may times, the maximum rate threshold had not once been exceeded. This gave rise to a conclusion  by the Court that the agreement was unfair since the minimum and maximum rates were not applied in a similar fashion.

Second similar judgment in one week

Regarding the order to repay the €17,000 which had been paid to the bank purely as a result of the clause, the Court ruled that the obligation to repay the money arose once the clause was deemed to be unfair. Considering those circumstances in which it would not be correct for the money to be repaid, the Court alluded to prior decisions of the Supreme Court and decided that  to order the return of €17,000 did not constitute a grave risk for the national economy or even of the affected bank.

This is the second judgment to emanate from the Basque Country in less than a week ordering a bank to repay mortgage payments due to the existence of an unfair ‘clausula suelo‘ in a mortgage agreement and it will be interesting to see how many similar judgments will follow.

You may be interested in the following service...

Client testimonials

"I have been working with Francisco for over 2 years. He is easy to reach very informative in all issues related to taxes in Spain for a foreigner.

Francisco is very professional and knowledgeable."

Dariusz Wiatrak (Feb 16, 2022)

Clausula Suelo

Available in the following locations: Alicante, Barcelona, Benidorm, Cadiz, Castellon, Córdoba, El Campello, Estepona, Fuengirola, Gandia, Girona, Granada, Jaen, L`Eliana, La Manga del Mar Menor, Las Palmas, Los Alcázares, Los Cristianos, Madrid, Mazarron, Murcia, Nerja, Orihuela Costa, Oviedo, Palma de Mallorca, Puerto del Rosario, Puzol, Seville, Torrevieja, Valencia, Velez Malaga, Vera, Vigo.

* If your local town is not listed, a lawyer from our nearest office will be happy to assist you.

Location

1Who is this Service for?

Spanish banks were penalised by the Courts for making their customers sign unfair contracts that allowed the banks to benefit from increased mortgage repayments on variable rate mortgages when the European Central Bank rate increased, but limited the extent of any reduction – and subsequent benefit to customers – when the ECB decreased

2What does this service consist of?

  • Initial discussion with the a English-speaking lawyer specialist in the field to determine if you may make a claim
  • Initial contact with the bank, as per procedure before filing claim
  • Upon failure of bank to make an appropriate offer, filing of the claim with the appropriate Court designated to hear such claims
  • Representation before the courts and processing of damages claim on your behalf
Support services

3Free Support Services Included

When combined with the free and innovative Advocate Abroad support services you can be sure that you are obtaining completely transparent legal services from registered and regulated English-speaking lawyers abroad.These support services include:

  • Verification of the regulatory status of your professional.
  • Fees as recommended by the Local Professional Body
  • Fees specified in advance and legally guaranteed.
  • Service levels agreed in advance and guaranteed.
  • All professionals must hold professional indemnity insurance.
  • Professionals' proficiency in English monitored.
  • Continuous quality controls and reviews.

Why choose Advocate Abroad?

AdvocateAbroad.com Message
Established more than
10 years ago
Present in 20
European Countries
Over 30,000 client enquiries
successfully managed