The Marital Home
The matrimonial home is a special type of asset that in certain circumstances may be treated differently from other assets following the dissolution of a marriage.
In the simple scenario where there are no children and the spouses own equal shares of the property, there may be an agreement to sell the property and divide the proceeds equally.
Alternatively one of the spouses may buy the other’s portion and retain the entire property alone.
Should one of the spouses refuse to sell either to the other or to third parties it is possible to have a judicial auction of the property, known as ‘actio communi dividundo’. However, this solution is not recommended as it takes time and is very costly.
Where there are children a different analysis is applied because the protection of the children becomes the priority.
Typically a court in Spain will give the mother of the children custody and, consequently, the use and enjoyment of the matrimonial home. This conferral may be given a time limit, for example, until the children reach the age of majority.
While the above scenarios vary in complexity, they are fairly common place. More unusual circumstances do arise from time to time requiring answers to difficult legal quandries such as: what happens when the property used by the couple during the marriage is in fact owned by the parents of the non-custodial parent who no longer has use and enjoyment of the property.
Complications have also arisen as a result of circumstances where the spouse awarded use and enjoyment of the property later shares the property with a new partner who might be seen to benefit from the fact that the non-custodial parent is paying perhaps one half of the mortgage.
Family Law Client Testimonials
Client reviews of our family law services, as uploaded by clients directly to the Wufoo survey platform:
- Wendy Dickson, MarbellaTuesday, June 19, 2018It was all done very quick. Very good value for money. How easy it all was to communicate via email.
- Liezl Pulido, PhilippinesMonday, April 23, 2018Rosa never stopped working very hard, she went way above what she needed to do...she never gave up on me and always did more than I thought anyone would.
I am so blessed I got Rosa to help me I co...uldn't have gotten a better lawyer she's the best.
Thank you Rosa from the bottom of my heart you are a wonderful person, I am so grateful to you.
- Julie Smith, TorrellanoFriday, April 20, 2018I can't compliment my solicitor enough.
From our initial meeting right through to my ultimate divorce (with no unpleasant surprises the entire duration of the entire process), he immediately respo...nded to my many enquiries, always had mine and my daughter's best interests at the forefront of any considerations and was well worth every penny of his extremely reasonable fee.
Excellent value for money, totally approachable and very professional and understanding. I highly recommend him and will continue to retain his services for other matters in the future.
- David Pratt, Alhaurin del GrandeFriday, April 13, 2018Alvaro gives me confidence that he understands the issue and gives me practical solutions. He works rapidly and efficiently. I would strongly recommend his services.
- John Burchell, Arroyo De la MielTuesday, March 20, 2018Alvaro was very professional, helpful and friendly. Understood things quickly. Explained things well in English. Very easy to contact at any time.
- Robert Davies, MallorcaMonday, March 12, 2018Very supportive and clear on producing a suitable divorce settlement. Efficient, understanding and professional.
- Adam Clark, TenerifeFriday, March 09, 2018Oliver was very professional. He explained things very clearly and honestly at all times and in the end we got the best result possible in my particular case.
Many thanks to him for his high level ...of service.
- Holly, LanzaroteFriday, February 23, 2018The divorce process could have been explained more clearly and accurately so that a more realistic time for completion can be attained.
- Tamara Malcolm, MallorcaTuesday, February 20, 2018Rosa was and is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Her advice was excellent and i will definitely be using her expertise again in the future.
- Eric Van Der Straeten, BelgiumFriday, November 17, 2017Mr. Sempere Gelardo was a pleasure to work with. This lawyer has an understanding of difficult matters that surpasses most of his colleagues.
He replied to my demand the next day and in fluent Engl...ish assisted me in the case I presented to him.
His professionalism, together with a lot of empathy, gave me a feeling of security. The results were of the same high standard.
I can only thank him and would recommend him to anybody who is in need of legal assistance in the region of Alicante.
- S Smith, EsteponaTuesday, September 12, 2017Being English in Spain and fighting a child custody and divorce case here is extremely difficult.
I originally had an only Spanish speaking lawyer and after 2 years of everything taking ages inclu...ding just responses from my lawyer plus with the language barrier I decided to make the difficult decision to change my lawyer to Alvaro.
Immediately and quickly Alvaro got an understanding of the case and was able to advise me. I was now able to understand myself what was going on and he worked to a new pace that had previously been lacking and that was needed to win the case.
Communication and response from Alvaro was always immediate and his recommendations were always correct. He is very professional and approachable person, and a very good lawyer. With his help and guidance I won the case and without any hesitation I would highly recommend Alvaro as a lawyer to anyone.
- Aaron L, OregonWednesday, August 02, 2017Very satisfied with the service provided. Helen was knowledgeable, helpful and responsive to communication. Will definitely use again.
- Maya M, CanadaMonday, July 31, 2017My overall experience with Rosa was a positive one.
Value for the money? Yes.
In my opinion, Rosa is a very knowledgeable and professional lawyer, who is able to not only understand the situat...ion at hand, but also suggest different approaches and customized solutions for unique, non-standard situations, which was the case with me.
And for that I am really happy and grateful to have worked with Rosa, and wish her the very best in the future.
- N. Gardiner, MijasFriday, June 16, 2017Rosa was value for money, really easy to deal and very efficient. Highly recommend.
- D slocombe, SpainFriday, May 19, 2017Jose is very friendly and understanding. I am very satisfied and I would you use the same lawyer again in the future.
- KSC, IrelandTuesday, October 18, 2016She was very helpful, always happy to assist. I was very satisfied with the service.
- Elena, AustraliaTuesday, June 14, 2016Rosa was straightforward, friendly, polite and cheap. I was very satisfied and I definitely would use the same lawyer again in the future.
- Kate Godbehere, GranadaThursday, February 25, 2016From the outset, Rosa was extremely professional, approachable, efficient and competent. Her level of English is extraordinary, something very much appreciated as it made life easier for me during an ...inherently difficult time.
Her correspondence was always relevant, detailed, simply and clearly explained and expressed. Rosa was kindly, matter of fact, calm, patient and always reassuring.
Her pro-active, intelligent, thoughtful and knowledgeable advice helped very much during a particularly delicate and worrying stage of the process.
- Peter Gural, La LineaThursday, October 08, 2015What I liked about this service: Value for money.
The level of professionalism and excellence in service was not compromised in the reasonably low fee charged for the service.
All details were... explained in a simple format that an ordinary citizen could understand, sparing the bureaucratic procedure that only lawyers can understand.
- Elena Todd, AlmoradiFriday, July 18, 2014Our lawyer was very understanding of our situation, and took a lot of time to strategise for the best possible outcome.
Her passionate performance in court exhibited a heartfelt commitment to our ...case.
Her fees were very reasonable and she was willing to consider payment terms at difficult times.
I strongly recommend her and will use her again in the future.
- Christine B., SpainThursday, July 03, 2014Very fast and comprehensive responses to all my queries.
Always available via email and telephone.
Very reasonable fees.Extremely helpful and thorough. Polite, perfect English. Absolutely prof...essional.
The Marital Home is Owned by the Parents of One of the Spouses
In the situation where the free use of the property was granted by the parents of the spouse who no longer has use and enjoyment of the property, the majority of the courts have decided that such a gift may be considered ‘precarious’ and therefore the situation could be terminated when deemed convenient by the true owners. i.e. the parents of the non-custodial parent.
The Spouse Granted Sole Use of the Home shares it with a new Partner
Regarding the situation where the use and enjoyment of a joint property is granted by the court to one of the spouses who later shares the property with a new partner, the question of whether the circumstances require a change in the use and enjoyment of the property would seem to depend on whether or not there are children involved.
Where there are no children, the use and enjoyment of the property will have been conceded to the particular spouse because the court will have evaluated the situation and decided that this spouse was more deserving of protection than the other.
Simply put, once that spouse is living with a new partner, the new circumstances may well be sufficient for the judge to consider, upon a request made by the former spouse and (at least part) owner of the property, that the situation that gave rise to the need for greater protection no longer exists and that the property should be returned to the former spouse or sold.
If, on the other hand there are children, the use and enjoyment is in reality indirect, as the use is really in favour of the children. Accordingly, should the spouse granted use and enjoyment of the property decide to share it with a new partner, this would not extinguish the rights enjoyed by the children.
Impact of a new Relationship
The above reasoning may be modified where the sharing of the property with the new partner may be considered detrimental in some way to the children, it being the interests of the children that are paramount in the eyes of the court at all times.
Other Relevant Factors
It has also been held by the Court of Appeal in Zaragoza, when applying the Law of Joint [Child] Custody passed by the Aragon Parliament a year ago, that where the property was owned solely by the father of the child, that the property should be returned to him once the child had reached the age of 12.
The Court decided that the mother being relatively young, and working, had the same responsibility to provide a house for her child as the father.
Responsibility for the Mortgage
Any mortgage remains the liability of those who signed it so, for example, in the case where both spouses are joint owners of the matrimonial home and both are signatories to the mortgage, then both remain equally liable after a divorce.
The financial institution is not concerned with the specific circumstances of the use and enjoyment of the property and so, the non-custodial parent who is no longer using the property must continue to pay the mortgage installments or face having the property repossessed.
Should the custodial parent start a new relationship it may be open to the non-custodial parent to make an application for a substantial change in circumstances in order to press for a sale of the property and division of the assets.