Non-appearance at oral hearing precluded later claim by tenant

The High Court in Mallorca has ruled against a tenant’s claims to have a right to stay in the defendant landlord’s property for a period of five years as per the then pertaining legislation which gave tenants a right to continue living in a property for a period of five years.

The Court heard that the tenant alleged to have agreed the verbal contract in June 2012 whereby the rent was set at 600€ per month and a sum of 1200€ was paid over to cover the first month’s rent plus deposit.  The rental contract was to be handed over in July, but this never happened. though the tenant considered that the landlord being an elderly gentleman was a man of his word and that a tenancy for five years had been created.  The Court noted that no proof of any of these events was offered by the tenant.

The Court’s Reasoning

The Court considered that the tenant did not have any right to be in the property, on the basis that:

  1. Having not attended the original oral hearing, it followed from the Civil Procedure Act that it may be imputed that the tenant had accepted the allegations of the other party, namely that he had no legal right to be in the property,
  2. There was a complete absence of any proof to support the tenant’s case,
  3. No rent had been paid, according to the tenant himself, since August 2012.
  4. Together with the fact that the tenant had requested legal aid (in the end not granted) the Court was driven to the conclusion that the proceedings were only entered into to gain more time in the property
  5. On the basis that the onus was on the tenant to show proof of a legal right to occupy the property and given the contradictory version of events, the continuing doubt should prejudice his claim.

In so finding, the Court heldin favour of the landlord and awarded costs against the tenant.

Related Services

39 Lawyers Offering Eviction Proceedings Services in Spain

Testimonials for our Eviction Proceedings service
  • Wayne Leatherbarrow
    Wayne Leatherbarrow, Costa Blanca

    Confident, articulate, concise & polite. I've used eleven 'abogados' to date, all pale behind Jose Sempre. One case I had lasted 12 years ! So I do believe that I know a little concerning the lugubrious trade today. The Best Rise to the Surface.

    I'm happy, Thank you.

    Sep 01, 2020
  • jake raby
    Jake Raby, Ibiza

    Cristina provided an excellent service throughout the process.

    During the initial telephone consultation, she provided clear advice about our legal position and options. She then dealt with the resolution of our property dispute efficiently and kept us informed regularly via email.

    Would definitely recommend to friends.

    Jun 01, 2020
  • Ilona Barta
    Ilona Barta, Torrevieja

    Inma was extremely helpful: she responded promptly and kept us up dated during our case every day. She possesses great negotiation skills that led to success in our case. Great value for money for complicated issue. Inma also made us clear about Spanish legislations and law that was helpful.

    Approachable and highly professional. Can't express enough our gratitude. We will definitely recommend Inma.

    Great service.

    May 29, 2020
  • Thijs Lethbridge
    Thijs Lethbridge, Murcia

    Maria is an extremely competent and professional lawyer, she helped with all aspects of work involved even going above and beyond in her line of duty. I will definitely use her again if I require a lawyer. Brilliant experience.

    Oct 23, 2019
  • Manoochehr Jafari-Nahad
    Manoochehr Jafari-Nahad, UAE

    Jose-Antonio was extremely helpful and prompt and also it was helpful that he could be contacted via social media like Whatsapp

    Oct 13, 2018
  • Colin Stuart Farmer
    Colin Stuart Farmer, UK

    Juan Ignacio met me in Almeria and with skill and persistence was able to deal with the eviction of a non paying tenant in a very short time, and avoided long and drawn out court processes.(The time factor was important because after gaining access it became apparent that the occupant was rapidly trashing the place.).

    At all times he maintained personal contact with continuous updates during the process.

    A great bloke, great job done and good value.

    Hopefully he can do the same for when I sell the place.

    Dec 15, 2017
  • Bjarne ten Harkel
    Bjarne ten Harkel, The Netherlands

    My lawyer Rossana is an honest person and highly professional. She is simpatico. I would definitely hire this lawyer again.

    Nov 22, 2017
  • Andrew Brown
    Andrew Brown, Qatar

    Francisco is extremely helpful, couldn’t have done more.

    He is absolutely first class and professional service. Provided over and above all my requirements.

    May 25, 2016
  • Allison Andrew
    Allison Andrew, Torrox

    My lawyer responded very quickly when contacted, and explained the appropriate legal solution to our problem, which very quickly had the desired effect.

    She had more or less fluent English and we would definitely use her services again.

    Nov 28, 2014
  • Ian H
    Ian H, UK

    Nothing was too much trouble, efficient and didn't charge for additional help when he could have done.

    Aug 06, 2014