Grandparents’ visitation rights upheld by Spanish Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has decided that neither poor relations nor a lack of any understanding between parents and grandparents can justify denying the grandparents access to their grandchildren. Accordingly, a visitation schedule should be established to provide for contact and communication between the grandparents and the child in the case before the Court despite the  poor relations between the mother and grandmother of the child.

The appeal was brought by the grandparents of a child against the decision of the High Court in Seville. The Sevillian court had refused to establish a visitation schedule so that the grandparents could maintain contact with the child on the basis of the young age of the child (three years old) and the poor relationship between the parents and the grandmother of the child.

According to the High Court, ‘the dire relationship between the grandmother and her daughter could have negative repercussions on the development and stability of the child,’ The Court believed that should the relations between the parents and grandparents improve and when the child was somewhat older, that ‘a desirable system of communication between the grandparent and the child could be established’.

 

Article 160 of the Civil Code

In considering the matter the Supreme Court considered  the meaning and extent of Article 160.2 of the Civil Code which states: It is not permitted to impede, unless there be just cause, the interpersonal relationship between a child and his or her grandparents.  It therefore becomes necessary to determine exactly what ‘just cause’ means.

According to the Supreme Court, ‘just cause’ does not mean circumstances where the parents and grandparents of the child simply do not maintain good relations. Moreover, it does not mean where there is no understanding or agreement as between the two parties.

The Supreme Court felt that there had been no definite explanation given as to how or why, in the case before it, the child would suffer any negative repercussions as a result of the poor relations between the parents and the grandmother and labelled that argument as merely speculative, in the absence of any demonstration to the contrary.

In this respect the Court did highlight the fact that the right of the grandparents to enjoy contact and communicate with the child could be suspended or limited if any ill will was shown by the child to the mother that could be attributed to the relationship with the grandmother.

 

Other Court Orders

In another case dealing with similar issues, the Supreme Court dismissed an appeal by a mother of two children and ordered that the children should visit with their grandparents one weekend a month. The order had in fact originated from the High Court in Badajoz which had directed that the children should stay one weekend a  month in the home of their deceased father’s parents as well as a week long visit during the holidays each year and a spend time with them each week.

While the Supreme Court stated that it did not consider it appropriate for this measure to be adopted generally, neither could it be rejected indiscriminately. The mother of the children, appealing the decision of the High Court, argued that it was not necessary to establish obligatory visitation periods as she was already facilitating contact with the family in any case.

On the other hand the grandparents argued that the relationship prior to the death of their son, the children’s father, had been extremely close as they had previously lived above the family workplace. In this particular case the High Court had approved visitation rights that consisted of two hours weekly, one weekend each month and one week from their holidays each year.

The Supreme Court agreed with the decision of the High Court, reasoning that although it was not the first time that such visitation rights had been awarded to grandparents that it should only be considered with regard to the circumstances of the particular case.

In the particular instance before the Court, the judges decided that the visitation rights that had been awarded by the High Court were reasonably moderate and respected the rights of the mother but also the rights of the children to maintain contact with their paternal family, which is a stabilising and emotionally enriching factor in the children’s upbringing.

Related Services

53 office locations

Testimonials for our Parental Child Abduction service
  • Keisha
    Keisha, Valencia

    Inmaculada was professional and also demonstrated compassion and understanding during this difficult period in my life.


    Apr 03, 2019
  • Wayne
    Wayne, Valencia

    Francisca was very informative and helpful. She handled my divorce professionally and made it easy for me throughout the process.


    Highly recommend and reasonable fees. Thank you, Francisca!


    Mar 16, 2019
  • Victoria Aspey
    Victoria Aspey, Lanzarote

    Erardo was always there to answer questions and help in any way he could. I will certainly use him again in the future.


    Mar 12, 2019
  • Wayne Cherry
    Wayne Cherry, London, England

    Francisca was very informative and attentive to all of my inquiries and concerns. I would definitely be going back to her if needing her services again and would recommend her brilliant services.


    Mar 09, 2019
  • Candy
    Candy, Cadiz

    Francisco was very responsive, supportive and understanding.


    Unfortunately, I had to use another lawyer who has helped me in another case.


    Feb 11, 2019
  • Florence
    Florence, Fuengirola

    The service was quick and satisfactory. I was impressed by the lawyer's work. Very professional, easy going and communicative. Everything was perfect!


    Jan 08, 2019
  • Ryan
    Ryan, Alicante

    José was an absolute professional from start to finish. Every deadline was met on time. José made the process for us extremely comfortable and straight forward.


    He went over and above his position to help us finalise certain things related to our case, and quite honestly, if you get an opportunity to use his services, you will be more than happy with the outcome.


    Thank you again José and I wish you the best for you and for your family!


    Jan 07, 2019
  • Lloyd
    Lloyd, Seville

    Rafael was always there for me. He catered to my schedule rather than me to his.


    Jan 07, 2019
  • Colin Wilson
    Colin Wilson, Australia

    Overall it was great. Rosa always answered all questions asked and provided clear, concise and well explained answers.


    When there was a delay in responding she did offer an apology which was appreciated. Rosa always instilled a sense of confidence that she knew exactly what was going on, what I was asking, and what the applicable law was.


    When not a Spanish local and dealing with her remotely, this provided great comfort in a sensitive matter.


    Oct 30, 2018
  • Alena Beerman (Santander)
    Alena Beerman (Santander)

    Jaime was wonderful - at first I had no idea how I'd get the support I needed in a country I don't know well and a language I'm not fluent in, and he made it a breeze. Would definitely use them again.


    Aug 24, 2018
  • David Pratt (Fuengirola)
    David Pratt (Fuengirola)

    Alvaro was helpful and knowledgeable. My problem was solved rapidly and effectively.


    May 04, 2018
  • Julie Smith
    Julie Smith, Torrellano

    I can't compliment my solicitor enough.


    From our initial meeting right through to my ultimate divorce (with no unpleasant surprises the entire duration of the entire process), he immediately responded to my many enquiries, always had mine and my daughter's best interests at the forefront of any considerations and was well worth every penny of his extremely reasonable fee.


    Excellent value for money, totally approachable and very professional and understanding. I highly recommend him and will continue to retain his services for other matters in the future.


    Apr 20, 2018
  • David Pratt
    David Pratt, Alhaurin del Grande

    Alvaro gives me confidence that he understands the issue and gives me practical solutions. He works rapidly and efficiently. I would strongly recommend his services.


    Apr 13, 2018
  • John Burchell
    John Burchell, Arroyo De la Miel

    Alvaro was very professional, helpful and friendly.


    Understood things quickly. Explained things well in English. Very easy to contact at any time.


    Mar 20, 2018
  • Robert Davies
    Robert Davies, Mallorca

    Very supportive and clear on producing a suitable divorce settlement.


    Efficient, understanding and professional.


    Mar 12, 2018
  • Tamara Malcolm
    Tamara Malcolm, Mallorca

    Rosa was and is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Her advice was excellent and i will definitely be using her expertise again in the future.


    Feb 20, 2018
  • Eric Van Der Straeten
    Eric Van Der Straeten, Belgium

    Mr. Sempere Gelardo was a pleasure to work with. This lawyer has an understanding of difficult matters that surpasses most of his colleagues.


    He replied to my demand the next day and in fluent English assisted me in the case I presented to him.


    His professionalism, together with a lot of empathy, gave me a feeling of security. The results were of the same high standard.


    I can only thank him and would recommend him to anybody who is in need of legal assistance in the region of Alicante.


    Nov 17, 2017
  • Aaron L
    Aaron L, Oregon

    Very satisfied with the service provided. Helen was knowledgeable, helpful and responsive to communication. Will definitely use again.


    Aug 02, 2017
  • D slocombe
    D slocombe, Spain

    Jose is very friendly and understanding.


    I am very satisfied and I would you use the same lawyer again in the future.


    May 19, 2017
  • Sharon williams
    Sharon williams, London

    Christina was very helpful and a good listener to what my worries and needs were.


    She responded to what I needed very professionally and sufficiently. I will and shall be using Christina again if necessary.


    Mar 10, 2017
  • MG
    MG, Castellon

    Lidia was really helpful and answered my questions clearly.


    I would definitely use the same lawyer again in the future.


    Feb 16, 2017
  • Louise Kirby
    Louise Kirby, Alicante

    Jose Antonio is a very dedicated lawyer. He ensures he has a deep understanding of the case and provides excellent advise on a range of issues.


    He has often replied to queries out of hours and works hard to provide the best outcome for his clients.


    His service is outstanding and I would highly recommend him.


    Feb 15, 2017
  • Stanley Jones
    Stanley Jones, Llano del Camello

    I am very satisfied with Oliver, he was very helpful and always happy to assist.


    I would definitely use the same lawyer again in the future.


    Jan 17, 2017
  • Malcolm John Lewis
    Malcolm John Lewis, Germany

    Totally professional and helpful in every way, helped to solve problems that arose and so would recommend to anyone.


    Dec 15, 2016
  • Raquel Flores Camua
    Raquel Flores Camua, Abbotsford

    Rossana was excellent in all these qualities – responsiveness, understanding, value for money, ability to explain and provide appropriate legal solutions, approachability and professionalism.


    Couldn’t ask for more, extremely satisfied with her service and sincere attention to my interests.


    Dec 12, 2016
  • Centa P Cronin
    Centa P Cronin, Fuerteventura

    Beatriz was very friendly…easy to engage with….efficient service.


    She couldn’t have done more.


    Nov 26, 2016
  • CW
    CW, Ibiza

    Very knowledgeable and supportive from the outset.


    Made to feel very comfortable and nothing was too much trouble. Very highly recommended.


    Nov 22, 2016
  • Nick C
    Nick C, London

    I have to say he was excellent. Perfect English.I was dreading it and he appreciated my position and showed a lot of empathy.


    Fernando was very responsive with very quick turnaround. Explained all areas of the law in an understandable and uncomplicated way. Professional and cost effective.


    I deal with a lot with lawyers through my business and he is one of the best ones I have come across.


    Nov 04, 2016
  • Abi Carr
    Abi Carr, Mijas Costa

    Alvaro assisted me through an extremely difficult and complex situation. At all times he was professional, reassuring and diligent, explaining anything I did not quite understand, and working tirelessly on my behalf.


    He kept me informed throughout, always responding to my calls and emails very quickly. Excellent service, and value for money. I highly recommend Alvaro. I would not hesitate to use him again.


    Oct 28, 2016
  • Michael Anthony
    Michael Anthony, Malaysia

    I found Francisco to be very understanding of my needs and was able to discuss frankly with him on sensitive and personal matters.


    I found Francisco to be extremely professional, helpful, knowledgeable and importantly very approachable. I would certainly recommend him to anyone who needed such services and I would certainly use him and his law firm again if the need arose.


    Aug 19, 2016
  • Michelle Richardson
    Michelle Richardson, UK

    Domingo has great empathy, and works hard with great understanding of your needs.


    Domingo is available and flexible, he is there for you always, and very professional at all times.


    My case was a difficult one,Domingo did all he could given the circumstances, I could not of have asked for more.


    Apr 19, 2016
  • Kate Godbehere
    Kate Godbehere, Granada

    From the outset, Rosa was extremely professional, approachable, efficient and competent. Her level of English is extraordinary, something very much appreciated as it made life easier for me during an inherently difficult time.


    Her correspondence was always relevant, detailed, simply and clearly explained and expressed. Rosa was kindly, matter of fact, calm, patient and always reassuring.

    Her pro-active, intelligent, thoughtful and knowledgeable advice helped very much during a particularly delicate and worrying stage of the process.


    Feb 25, 2016
  • Ian Bailey (Mallorca)
    Ian Bailey (Mallorca)

    I recently used Rosa and found her service excellent!


    May 31, 2015
  • Thomas Hills
    Thomas Hills, Spain

    Legally I believe everything was covered in what I think was a complicated situation, so I am satisfied that I was well represented.


    No problems were encountered with language, as the lawyer had perfect English. Meetings were scheduled and kept, which is good for Spain !

    Overall I am very satisfied with the service.


    Mar 13, 2015
  • Kevin Neylon
    Kevin Neylon, Poland

    Jaime was very responsive, represented value for money and was very professional and helpful.


    I was very satisfied with his advice.


    Feb 23, 2015
  • Anthony Op de Weegh
    Anthony Op de Weegh, Switzerland

    My lawyer was bilingual and extremely helpful, she could not have done more.


    I also liked that she acted extremely quickly. I had no time before a flight and she did everything including dealing with government officials which is hard in Spain.


    Oct 22, 2014
  • Brett Goldsmith
    Brett Goldsmith, Canada

    He helped me not to put certain points in my divorce, that I later may have regretted. Often in haste a person will ask for or give certain concessions that later will be inappropriate.


    I was fortunately stopped from doing this by my lawyer Pedro.


    Pedro has a professional, helpful and friendly approach.


    Sep 21, 2014
  • Maureen Brown
    Maureen Brown, Benidorm

    Juan kept us up to date on everything.


    He was very understanding, very good value for money, explained everything we needed explained. We understood everything he told us. His English was first class


    The service from Juan was first class. We would recommend him to anyone.


    May 23, 2014
Send Your Enquiry
Are there public holidays?

Enquiry sent. Thank you!

Please fix errors