Contact in Spain
Spain: +34 932 20 44 40
UK: 0800 098 8033
US: +1 415 651 8449

Have a Cláusula Suelo attached to your Mortgage in Spain?

The Spanish Supreme Court has set-out rules that the banks must comply with in order that they may rely on the so-called ‘Cláusulas Suelo’ , which are clauses in the mortgage agreement which allow the banks to limit the extent to which their borrowers can benefit from the extremely low interest rate environment currently prevailing in Europe and beyond.

Most variable mortgage rates in Spain are set with reference to the Euribor rate, an average based on what 50 European banks pay to borrow. In Spain the banks have tended to establish in the mortgage agreement a minimum interest rate, regardless of whether the Euribor goes even lower.

‘Cláusulas suelo’ have been a bone of contention for some time and judges in the lower courts have agreed, forcing banks to appeal up through the Courts, with the matter finally being addressed by the Spanish Supreme Court in Madrid, in May this year.

The decision sets a precedent that must be followed by all lower courts and the specific case referred to the Supreme Court involved the BBVA, NCG and Caja Rurales banks. While the clauses did not constitute an ‘unfair term’, they did need to be ‘comprehensible’ and ‘transparent’.

Conditions for Inclusion

In it’s decision the Supreme Court stressed the need for any such clauses ‘to pass the test of transparency with regard to the fact that it is included as a general condition of the contract…’

In the case before it, the Court decided that the relevant clauses were null and void since they were not transparent as they were bundled together with the opposing “Ceiling clauses” which restrict the upper limit of interest payments in an apparent ‘quid pro quo’ In addition, there were no simulations offered as to the financial impact the clauses might have.

Also important according to the Court was the fact that there was no ‘clear and comprehensible’ information given regarding the comparative cost of the mortgage as opposed to other mortgage offerings from the same banks.  Specifically the Court highlighted the fact that in the particular case before it, ‘any warnings were drowned in an overwhelming mass of data whereby the attention of the consumer is diverted’.

Impact

This specific judgment only literally affects the financial organisations involved. The more general impact of the judgment would seem to be that the inclusion of such clauses in mortgage agreements – as long as they carry the necessary health risks – has now been sanctified by the highest Court in Spain.

Also  important was that the Court stated explicitly that the decision was not retroactive,  such that any payments made under such a clause would not be returned to the borrower since this would potentially destabilise the economy.

For those with mortgages in Spain therefore, whether or not you are affected will depend on the manner in which any such clause in your mortgage agreement has been drafted. If in doubt you should contact a lawyer to review the mortgage agreement and get an expert opinion as to whether you can have the interest rate on your mortgage reduced.

You may be interested in the following service...

Client testimonials

"I thought he was very helpful and professional, always responded quickly.

His English is really good and all the instructions I received concerning the signing and returning of documents was very clear.

I would readily recommend him."

Nicole Spires (May 26, 2020)

Clausula Suelo

Available in the following locations: Alicante, Barcelona, Benidorm, Cadiz, Castellon, Córdoba, El Campello, Estepona, Fuengirola, Gandia, Girona, Granada, Jaen, L`Eliana, La Manga del Mar Menor, Las Palmas, Los Alcázares, Los Cristianos, Madrid, Mazarron, Murcia, Nerja, Orihuela Costa, Oviedo, Palma de Mallorca, Puerto del Rosario, Puzol, Seville, Torrevieja, Valencia, Velez Malaga, Vera, Vigo.

* If your local town is not listed, a lawyer from our nearest office will be happy to assist you.

Location

1Who is this Service for?

Spanish banks were penalised by the Courts for making their customers sign unfair contracts that allowed the banks to benefit from increased mortgage repayments on variable rate mortgages when the European Central Bank rate increased, but limited the extent of any reduction – and subsequent benefit to customers – when the ECB decreased

2What does this service consist of?

  • Initial discussion with the a English-speaking lawyer specialist in the field to determine if you may make a claim
  • Initial contact with the bank, as per procedure before filing claim
  • Upon failure of bank to make an appropriate offer, filing of the claim with the appropriate Court designated to hear such claims
  • Representation before the courts and processing of damages claim on your behalf
Support services

3Free Support Services Included

When combined with the free and innovative Advocate Abroad support services you can be sure that you are obtaining completely transparent legal services from registered and regulated English-speaking lawyers abroad.These support services include:

  • Verification of the regulatory status of your professional.
  • Fees as recommended by the Local Professional Body
  • Fees specified in advance and legally guaranteed.
  • Service levels agreed in advance and guaranteed.
  • All professionals must hold professional indemnity insurance.
  • Professionals' proficiency in English monitored.
  • Continuous quality controls and reviews.

Why choose Advocate Abroad?

AdvocateAbroad.com Message
Established more than
10 years ago
Present in 20
European Countries
Over 30,000 client enquiries
successfully managed